#4 65 Votes:

Carolina Lady

The Pearsall Brothers Band

#5 47 Votes:

Daddy Doesn't Pray Anymore

#6 43 Votes:

Jessie Lynn

#7 26 Votes:

Farmers Daughters

Cindy Larson

#8 25 Votes:

Ava Paige Bait His Own Hook

Ava Paige

#9 17 Votes:

Hoss Pair Of Queens

#10 12 Votes:

Catch Me

Maggie Baugh

#11 9 Votes:

Tailights

September Campbell

#12 9 Votes:

Along Came Mary

Marion Fiedler

#13 8 Votes:

Do You Hear What I Hear

Steve Dunfee

#14 7 Votes:

Every Single Christmas

#15 6 Votes:

My Unsung Hero

Dede Wedekind

#16 6 Votes:

Neck Of The Woods

#17 4 Votes:

Sing Like No Ones Watching

#18 2 Votes:

All I Want For Xmas Is You

#19 1 Votes:

Stop My Heart

#20 1 Votes:

Brian Bouchie Christmas Love